Preacher
The Preacher chooses a player. If they chose a Minion: Put the Preacher to sleep. Wake the target. Show the THIS CHARACTER SELECTED YOU token and the Preacher token.
Godfather
Show the character tokens of all in-play Outsiders.
Witch
The Witch chooses a player.
Mezepheles
Show the written word.
Pukka
The Pukka chooses a player.
Grandmother
Point to the grandchild player & show their character token.
Seamstress
The Seamstress might choose 2 players. Nod or shake your head.
Chambermaid
The Chambermaid chooses 2 living players. Give a finger signal.